16 Comments

This was a new one for me, and I loved it. That's not too surprising, since almost all of my favorite XTC songs are ones Moulding wrote.

Expand full comment
author

Yeah, it's impressive when you go through each album and pick out the Moulding songs, how they are usually the highlights. Kind of like how Stewart Copeland wrote most of the best songs from The Police. (I jest -- just trying to kick the beehive...)

Expand full comment

Here's a different take from what I guess you'll be getting: I've never heard this song before! First reaction....interestingly jazzy, the cymbal-tapping and the piano playing, in particular. For the record, while I was an XTC fan, I wasn't rabid, and missed a few LPs along the way. But, I certainly found them melodic and creative, and made it a point to, at least, keep up with what they were doing from album to album! BTW, I like you in short-form, Steve! Not INSTEAD OF your certainly-loved Earworm pieces, but this short form suits you as a sideline I'd like to see you pursue more frequently....as well as doing song reviews/dissections like this!😁👍❕

Expand full comment
author

Thanks, Brad! I created the "TWEET"s just for this purpose! To have a short form offering to break up the longer pieces. Hence the semi-forced acronym! Also as a personal in-joke because I'm not a Twitter user.:)

And I would expect many of the readers not to have heard this song before. I would bet even some big XTC fans might not have heard it. I was playing all my XTC albums on shuffle and this one came on and I was reminded of what brilliant songwriters and musicians Andy, Colin, Dave, et al. are/were. Not that I needed a reminder at all, but as I hadn't heard this song in years it jumped out at me.

Expand full comment
Jun 16, 2023Liked by Steve Goldberg

Haven't heard this one in years! So great! And yet another example of a lead songwriter/control freak holding down a great junior partner -- e.g. Lennon/McCartney and Harrison

Expand full comment
Jun 16, 2023Liked by Steve Goldberg

Like, can anybody seriously argue that Lennon was writing better tunes around 1968/1969 than Harrison?

There's an alternate universe (in my mind, lol!) where the Beatles stay together, Lennon kinda leans out a bit, and they make a new album in 1970/71 filled with Harrison's best tunes from All Things Must Pass. But without the Phil Spector bombast. Man, that woulda been great.

Expand full comment
author

Ira, I imagine you know that two years ago for the 50th anniversary of All Things Must Pass, a Spector-less (or reduced?) remix was included. So you now have that option. https://www.georgeharrison.com/atmp50/

Expand full comment
Jun 16, 2023Liked by Steve Goldberg

Really?!? đŸ€Ż

Expand full comment

"Phil Spector bombast": How many times has THAT phrase been written?! That third word almost became part of his name! Ira, you may have seen it, but in case I released it before you came aboard FR&B (and, I'm hoping Steve won't mind), here's my George take from a year ago, mainly focusing on "What is Life," Spector bombast and all, newly-freed from behind the dreaded paywall: https://bradkyle.substack.com/p/beatle-royale-dont-bother-me-and

Expand full comment

Can you imagine John, Paul and Ringo supporting George on All Things Must Pass instead of Spector and the Schmaltz-ettes?!?

Expand full comment

Well, yeah, but like anyone who "breaks free" from any previous musical endeavor (no matter how glorious, life-changing, and/or lucrative), the desire is strong to REALLY break free!

Expand full comment
author

That's it Brad, detention for you after class! Bring your pencil and notebook and get ready to write 500 times, "I will not self-promote in the comment section of Steve's substack..." Okay, I'll allow it this one time!:) Or however many times you deem proper.

Expand full comment

"Detention?! Aw, Mr. G, that's not FAIR! You're a meany!" As for writing on the blackboard, I think I saw Bart writing that very sentence on a "Simpsons" open, once! As Billy Shakespeare once wrote, "Hamlet, you're a prince!"😉

Expand full comment

Long time XTC fan here! What a liquidy-smooth track, some tasty playing by Dave in the background. I adore Andy's work but Colin does get short shrift at times... he's the Paul to Andy's John in many ways. And it's a very timely message.

Expand full comment
author

Yeah, Colin is the Paul to Andy's John. I am imagining Colin a bit less willing to push back against Andy than Paul to John. But I could be wrong. He did have 5 songs on Skylarking, though I would bet that was more Rundgren's call. And Dave Gregory is the George Harrison, the secret sauce for many of their best songs.

Expand full comment